Case Name: Cosurge LLC v. Amit Yadav / CoSurge Consulting Private Limited (FORUM Claim Number: FA2609002245248)
Date of Decision: October 19, 2026
Introduction
MAHESHWARI & CO. successfully represented CoSurge Consulting Private Limited in a domain name dispute brought before FORUM under ICANN’s Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (“the Policy”). CoSurge LLC, a United States accounting firm, sought transfer of our client’s domain name <co-surge.com> (“the Domain Name”), alleging that it had been registered in bad faith to target the Complainant’s United States market.
The Panel ruled in our client’s favor, finding that the Domain Name relates to its accounting business. It held that the Complainant had failed to prove both the absence of rights or legitimate interests and bad faith, denied the transfer, and ordered that the Domain Name remain with CoSurge Consulting.
Background Of The Case
Our client’s director registered the domain name on April 3, 2025. CoSurge Consulting Private Limited was incorporated on April 22, 2025, and obtained GST and Udyam registrations in June 2025. Further, it applied to register COSURGE CONSULTING in India in November 2025. The Complainant, on the other hand, only had pending United States applications on the date the Domain Name was registered and finally obtained its registrations on June 3, 2025, and filed the Complaint on September 14, 2026.
Issues Before The Panel
- Whether CoSurge Consulting has rights or legitimate interests in the Domain Name under Paragraph 4(a)(ii) of the Policy?
- Whether the Domain Name was registered and is being used in bad faith under Paragraph 4(a)(iii) of the Policy?
- Whether the Complainant was entitled to transfer of the Domain Name?
Legal Provisions
- Paragraph 4(a) of the Policy: the Complainant must prove all three elements to obtain a transfer.
- Paragraph 4(b) of the Policy: the circumstances evidencing bad faith registration and use.
- Rule 15(a) of the UDRP Rules: the Panel decides on the statements and documents submitted.
Our Arguments and the Panel’s Findings
We argued that the name CoSurge was formed from the ordinary English words “co” and “surge” and was chosen without any knowledge of the Complainant. The Panel agreed that our client was right that these are ordinary English words whose combination could have been chosen independently, and held that if this were the case then our client would have legitimate rights and interests in it.
Further, we pointed out that on April 3, 2025, the Complainant had no reputation in India. The panel found that the Complainant had not shown any reputation in India and that our client is an Indian firm with Indian clients, and that references to a United States office which never materialised did not establish that our client had examined United States applications before registering the Domain Name.
We also brought it to FORUM’s notice that on April 3, 2025, the Complainant had only pending applications and regional use in the United States. The Panel noted that its registrations were issued only after the Domain Name was registered and that the Complainant had not established that its mark had acquired fame.
It was also our argument that circumstances under Paragraph 4(b) were not present. The Panel also found no direct evidence that the Domain Name was directed at the Complainant, no evidence that our client had the United States in mind at registration, and no evidence that it offered the Domain Name for sale, registered other similar domain names, or sought to disrupt the Complainant’s business. The Complainant’s two clients had themselves recognized that our client was a different company in India, which the Panel held showed neither actual confusion nor an intent to attract the Complainant’s customers for commercial gain.
Conclusion
The Panel held that the Complainant failed to discharge its burden under Paragraphs 4(a)(ii) and 4(a)(iii). Hence, they were denied the relief sought, and it was ordered that <co-surge.com> remain with CoSurge Consulting Private Limited. The decision thus secures our client’s domain name and online identity and illustrates that a name independently adopted for a genuine business, before the trademark owner’s rights were registered and without any reputation in the registrant’s market, cannot be taken away through the Policy merely because it resembles a foreign mark.

